Here We Go Again: Summum v. Pleasant Grove | American Center for Law and Justice
  Search  |  Login  |  Register

ACLJ Profile Completion

Verified

By Geoffrey Surtees1320706010000

Over two years ago, in Pleasant Grove City v. Summum, the ACLJ obtained a unanimous victory in the U.S. Supreme Court allowing a city to display a donated Ten Commandments monument in a public park without having to display any and all donated monuments, donated by any and all private groups.

The lawsuit was brought by Summum, a religious organization founded in 1975 and headquartered in Salt Lake City, Utah. In the Summum decision, the Supreme Court unequivocally rejected Summum’s First Amendment free speech claim that because the City was publicly displaying a Ten Commandments monument donated by the Fraternal Order of Eagles it had to display the group’s “Seven Aphorisms” monument as well. The Court wrote that when it comes to displaying monuments on public lands — a historical practice of governments since time immemorial — the government is the speaker and has the right to “speak for itself,” “say what it wishes,” and “select the views it wants to express.”

After the U.S. Supreme Court rejected its free speech claim, Summum amended its complaint and argued instead that Pleasant Grove had violated the federal establishment clause. The U.S. District Court in Utah dismissed Summum’s newly minted claim, writing that “there is no evidence that anyone in Pleasant Grove government had any idea what Summum’s religious beliefs were, and thus it cannot be said that the Pleasant Grove government demonstrated a preference for one religion over another.”

Almost one year after losing its federal establishment clause claim in federal court, Summum has filed suit yet again. This time, Summum has turned to Utah state court, alleging that Pleasant Grove violated the Utah State Constitution in not allowing Summum to display its private monument. The ACLJ will once again represent Pleasant Grove City. While the Utah state establishment clause is different in content than the federal establishment clause, we believe Summum’s state claim will ultimately fail. Contrary to the allegations in Summum’s new complaint, Pleasant Grove City has not impermissibly discriminated against Summum and its monument. The criteria consistently followed by the City to help determine whether to accept and display a donated monument does not allow city officials to consider the religious tenets or beliefs of the donor.

In the end, we believe the Utah Courts will follow the lead of the U.S. Supreme Court and hold that Pleasant Grove City is free to display its own Ten Commandments monument without having to display every monument, donated by any group.

Our responses to Summum’s motions for preliminary relief and summary judgment are due on December 23, 2011. We will keep you posted as the case progresses.

ACLJ Defends Legislative Prayer

By Edward White1494338952909

As many legislative bodies do, the Jackson County, Michigan, Board of Commissioners starts its meetings with a prayer. The American Center for Law and Justice (“ACLJ”) has filed an amicus curiae (“friend-of-the-court”) brief with the United States Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit supporting...

read more

ACLJ Defends School Board Opening in Prayer

By Geoffrey Surtees1493836082751

Can a public school board offer a prayer or invocation prior to a meeting of the board? As we argue in a brief filed with the Ninth Circuit today, the answer to that question is yes . In 2014, the Chino Valley Unified School District Board of Education adopted a resolution permitting local...

read more

Latest Atheists' Attack on National Motto

By Laura Hernandez1487279631749

Litigious atheists never give up – at least when it comes to continuing their failing, but relentless, crusade against our National Motto – “In God We Trust.” Appealing their latest defeat to the Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit, the atheists, represented by Michael Newdow, challenged the...

read more

Honoring Those Who Serve on Veterans Day

By Wesley Smith1478796139234

Veterans Day is Friday, November 11th. Formerly known as Armistice Day, this holiday was originally created to commemorate the end of World War I, which officially took place on November 11, 1918. In legislation that was passed in 1938, November 11th was "dedicated to the cause of world peace and...

read more