Victory: “No Atheists in Foxholes” Article Reinstated on Chaplain’s Website | American Center for Law and Justice
  Search  |  Login  |  Register

ACLJ Profile Completion


Victory: Chaplain’s Article Reinstated

By Matthew Clark1376662654000

Angry atheists bizarre arguments and incendiary tactics were once again exposed and soundly defeated as a military chaplain’s blog post has been reposted on a base website.

A few weeks ago we told you about a military chaplain’s website posting that was inappropriately censored and removed after the Military Religious Freedom Foundation (MRFF) demanded it.

The inaptly named MRFF, an anti-Christian organization headed by Mikey Weinstein, makes it its mission to antagonize military chaplains for doing their duty.  Weinstein has compared Christians serving in our military to al Qaeda and repeatedly refers to Christians in uniform as “monsters who terrorize.”

MRFF again ramped up its anti-Christian rhetoric and illogical demands when Air Force Chaplain, Lt. Col. Kenneth Reyes posted an article exploring the history and context of the phrase, “No atheists in foxholes,” on the Chaplains Corner blog of Joint Base Elmendorf-Richardson.  MRFF sent a letter demanding the posting be taken down calling it “bigoted, religious supremacist,” “condescending bile,” and “[f]aith based hate.”

The article itself, titled “'No atheists in foxholes': Chaplains gave all in World War II,” merely chronicled the historical context and origins of the famous phrase that was even quoted by President Dwight Eisenhower.

The chaplain’s articled opened:

Many have heard the familiar phrase, "There is no such thing as an atheist in a fox hole."  Where did this come from?

Research I verified in an interview with former World War II prisoner of war Roy Bodine (my friend) indicates the phrase has been credited to Father William Cummings.

As the story goes, Father Cummings was a civilian missionary Catholic priest in the Philippines.

The phrase was coined during the Japanese attack at Corregidor.

After exploring the context behind the statement and how Father Cummings’ contemporaries viewed it, the post closes by asking the simple question, “What is 'faith' to you?”

Hardly the hate-filled propaganda piece MRFF alleged.

Unfortunately, the posting was removed after the base received MRFF’s letter.  The ACLJ then sent a lengthy legal letter to the base both outlining MRFF’s long history of bullying Christians in the military and the clear constitutionality of this particular blog posting.

As our letter explained:

Trying to limit religious speech to avoid offending the non-religious would require military officials to determine which religious speech to allow and which to disallow, in effect, preferring certain types of religious speech over others, in itself something Government officials are precluded from doing by our Constitution.

We urged the military base, the Secretary of Defense, and the Secretary of the Air Force to return this post to its rightful place on the chaplain’s website.

We are pleased that after receiving our letter, the Air Force has republished the article on the military base website.  You can read Chaplain Reyes’ article here.

Latest in

Taking on California’s Lawless Agenda

By Harry G. Hutchison1520863200000

The long-simmering battle between the federal government and the state of California’s lawless agenda has erupted as part of escalating conflict last week after the Justice Department filed a lawsuit seeking to strike down the state’s attempt to usurp federal authority and write its own immigration...

read more

The Confirmation of Conservative Judges

By Nathanael Bennett1519398000000

One of the most important duties entrusted to our President and Senators is nominating and confirming competent and qualified judges for the federal courts. This task has a multi-generational impact, as federal judges serve a life-long tenure—sometimes spanning more than half a century—and will...

read more

Tax Reform is Working for Middle-Class Americans

By Harry G. Hutchison1516631437327

One of the largest successes of the last year is undoubtedly tax reform. The massive tax cuts package passed by Congress and signed by the President is a remarkable achievement – the largest tax cuts and simplification of the often bewildering tax code in decades. Indeed, whether it is tax reform,

read more

Conservative Judicial Nominations Update

By ACLJ.org1513616634820

At the ACLJ, we have been aggressively fighting for conservative judges on the federal bench. Over the last few months we have helped achieve unprecedented success. One of the most important duties facing a President and the U.S. Senate is the nomination and confirmation of federal judges. The...

read more