Victory in Religious Discrimination Case Against Pakistan’s Education Department | American Center for Law and Justice
  Search  |  Login  |  Register

ACLJ Profile Completion


Victory Against Pakistan Education Dept.

By Shaheryar Gill1478640376286

We are glad to inform you that we have successfully obtained a positive court decision for a young Christian who suffered religious discrimination by Pakistan’s Education Department. In 2010, Naeem Nazir, twenty-years-old at the time, applied for a post as an office assistant at a public school, but he was appointed as a sweeper (sanitation worker) because he was a Christian.

In March 2010, a daily newspaper, Nawa-i-Waqat, posted job advertisements for office assistants, sanitation workers, gardeners, etc., in public schools. Naeem submitted an application to the office of the Executive District Officer (EDO) at the Education Department in Pattoki, Kasur, for the post of office assistant. The same month Naeem was interviewed for the job. But the appointment letter he received from the Education Department stated that he was appointed as a sanitation worker. Such jobs are traditionally reserved for Christians on a discriminatory basis.  Last year, a Pakistani weekly, the Friday Times, reported that

Christians make up most of the non-Muslim minority in central Punjab and account for 1.5 per cent of the total population. Their representation in sanitation work, however, is above 80 percent. Data collected by World Watch Monitor states that 824 out of 935 sanitation workers in the Peshawar Municipal Corporation are Christian. About 6,000 out of 7,894 sanitation workers in the Lahore Waste Management Company are Christian. And 768 out of 978 workers in the Quetta Municipal Corporation are Christian. Islamabad’s Capital Development Authority (CDA) has 1,500 sanitation workers and all of them are Christian. Christians also have a very high representation in Gilgit and Karachi municipal corporations.

When Naeem informed the department that he had not applied for the post of sanitation worker, he was told to remain silent. Naeem then filed a complaint with the office of the District Coordination Officer (DCO). The DCO ordered the Education Department to appoint Naeem as an office assistant. But the Education Department did not implement the DCO’s order.

Naeem contacted the Organization for Legal Aid (OLA), affiliate office of the European Centre for Law and Justice (ECLJ) in Pakistan, in November 2010. We filed a petition in the Lahore High Court against the Department of Education, alleging violations of articles 4 (rights of individuals to be dealt with in accordance with law) and 25 (equality before law) of the Constitution of Pakistan and challenging the illegal appointments. After a six-year battle and numerous adjournments, justice was finally served.

During the court hearings it was revealed that all Christian applicants were only offered the jobs as janitors. On October 26, 2016, officials from the Education Department appeared before the court. Justice Muhammad Qasim Khan asked the EDO, Zulfiqar Ali, about the number of vacancies available for religious minorities. The EDO informed the court that there were twenty vacancies allotted for religious minorities. Justice Khan then asked him about the positions that were offered to Christians. The EDO replied that the Christians were only appointed as sanitation workers.

Justice Khan then ordered the EDO to immediately cancel Naeem’s appointment as a sanitary worker or he would suspend all officials who were involved in the illegal appointment. The EDO requested the court to give some time for Naeem’s new appointment as office assistant but the court ordered the EDO to submit Naeem’s new appointment letter before the court by October 28, 2016 or the court would summon the Secretary of Education to answer the allegations.

On October 28, the Education Department issued a new appointment letter to Naeem, appointing him as office assistant at a local public school.

Naeem told OLA that, while the case was going on, he continued his education and finished two years of college. He was also working at the National Database & Registration Authority (NADRA) office in Lahore as an office assistant. He had to travel daily for at least four to five hours to get to his job. After receiving his appointment letter from the Education Department, he can now work at an elementary school in his hometown and will not have to travel for hours every day. Naeem further told us that he wants to continue his studies to became a teacher.

This is a victory not only for Naeem but for the entire Pakistani Christian community that is systematically discriminated against due to its religion. The Friday Times report cited to above quotes “Professor Salamat Akhtar, a former professor of history at Gordon College in Rawalpindi,” who said,

as president of the All Pakistan College Teachers’ Association, he met the education secretary in Islamabad in 1980. ‘Not knowing I was a Christian, he said the government was worried that a large number of Christians were obtaining education… If all Christians were educated, then no one would be left to sweep the roads and pick up the garbage.’

Fortunately, due to officials like Justice Muhammad Qasim Khan who decided Naeem’s case, there is still hope. Your prayers and support are also crucial in fighting for the rights of the persecuted church around the world.

Celebrating 10 Years for Office Defending Pakistan's Christians

By Shaheryar Gill1584557151092

The ACLJ’s affiliate office in Pakistan recently celebrated its 10th anniversary defending religious freedom with clients, supporters, and staff. As you know, our European counterpart, the European Centre for Law and Justice (ECLJ), has an affiliated office in Pakistan, the Organization for Legal...

read more

Members of Congress Call for Release of Pastor Bryan Nerren

By Jordan Sekulow1584030702166

Members of Congress have just sent a critical letter to the foreign secretary of India calling for the immediate release of our client, American Pastor Bryan Nerren. Pastor Nerren is a U.S. Pastor from Tennessee who has been ministering in Nepal and India for almost two decades, training Sunday...

read more

ACLJ Delivers Critical Oral Intervention for Pastor John Cao

By CeCe Heil1583874539766

As we told you last week , Christian Pastor John Cao – a U.S. permanent resident from North Carolina – just marked a sad anniversary: his third year as a prisoner in China. We appeared before the U.N. Human Rights Council (HRC) urging the world’s leaders to take action to set him free. Pastor Cao...

read more

Pastor Cao Marks Third Year in Chinese Prison

By Jordan Sekulow1583440097982

A single day behind bars for being a Christian is one day too many. Christian Pastor John Cao – a U.S. permanent resident – has now been a prisoner in China for THREE YEARS. And now he faces a potential new threat to his safety. Pastor Cao spent decades serving the impoverished of China and Burma...

read more