ACLJ Files Amicus Brief Supporting Sixteen States’ Challenge to ObamaCare | American Center for Law and Justice
  Search  |  Login  |  Register

ACLJ Profile Completion

Verified

ACLJ Files Brief Supporting Challenge to ObamaCare

By Laura Hernandez1557865863648

The American Center for Law and Justice (ACLJ) has filed an amicus brief in a suit brought by 16 states and two individual plaintiffs challenging the constitutionality of ObamaCare’s individual mandate.  As you probably remember, the individual mandate required millions of Americans to buy and indefinitely maintain health insurance or face annual penalties.  

The ACLJ was involved in several challenges to the individual mandate after ObamaCare was initially enacted, either representing parties or filing amicus briefs.  We filed a critical amicus brief with the Supreme Court of the United States on behalf of 119 Members of Congress in 2012, and the Court agreed with us that the Commerce Clause of the Constitution did not authorize Congress to compel Americans to buy health insurance they did not want.  But, according to the Court, the individual mandate could be upheld as a constitutional exercise of Congress’s power to tax because the law imposed a tax penalty on people who did not purchase health insurance.  The Court’s decision to label the penalty a tax was surprising for many legal reasons, but also because Congress repeatedly assured Americans that ObamaCare would result in no new taxes.  

Fast forward to 2017. Congress passed the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act which, among many other things, eliminated the penalty for not purchasing health insurance.  In 2019, Americans no longer had to pay any tax for not complying with the individual mandate.  That was good news for those who had previously chosen to pay the penalty rather than buy expensive insurance they didn’t need.  But now the only reason that the individual mandate was constitutional was gone.  It remained as a bare command to buy insurance, and Congress does not have the power to issue such a bare command.

So sixteen states and two individual citizens sued in federal court asking that the individual mandate be held unconstitutional.  The district court agreed with the plaintiffs and the case is now pending before the Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit.  Our brief argues:

All three features that supported the [Supreme] Court’s “saving construction” of the individual mandate as a tax are now effectively nonexistent. This year, Americans were no longer required to make the shared responsibility payment with their income tax returns and were therefore not responsible for calculating their payment in accordance with such “familiar factors as taxable income, number of dependents, and joint filing status.” Because no payments have been made, no revenue will be generated. . . . And because the mandatory requirement no longer triggers a tax payment generating revenue for the government, the individual mandate is unmoored from any of Congress’s enumerated powers. 

Without a constitutional power to lean on, ObamaCare’s individual mandate, the linchpin of the law, must fall.

The court will hear oral argument in early July.

Defeat Unconstitutional ObamaCare Now

ObamaCare  Signatures

LOGIN

Receive the latest news, updates, and contribution opportunities from ACLJ.

$20
$40
$60
$120
$240
Make this a monthly tax-deductible gift.

As we battle in court to defeat unconstitutional, pro-abortion ObamaCare, we urgently need your support. Donate today.

Email Address is required.
First Name is required.
Last Name is required.
Credit Card Number is required.
Verification Code is required.
Expiration Month is required.
Expiration Year is required.
Receive the latest news, updates, and contribution opportunities from ACLJ.
Encourage your friends to sign and donate by sharing this petition.
Latest in
ObamaCare

IRS Paid Billions In Bogus ObamaCare Credits

By ACLJ.org1519243200000

Loopholes in President Obama’s signature legislative achievement have defrauded American taxpayers $3.5 Billion dollars in excess ObamaCare credits, and they can’t get it back. Reports indicate that the IRS paid a total of nearly $24 billion in ObamaCare subsidies in 2017. Of that figure, $5.8...

read more

Ending the ObamaCare Individual Mandate

By Harry G. Hutchison1510850681175

Last year shortly after the election, the ACLJ issued its Agenda for the Future . We urged the incoming administration to immediately repeal and replace ObamaCare with a focus on the advancement of a patient-centered, consumer-driven program that emphasizes choice and competition . Today, we renew...

read more

The President’s Executive Order on Healthcare

By ACLJ.org1507904666276

President Trump just signed an Executive Order “to Promote Healthcare Choice and Competition.” This Executive Order allows small businesses to unite to purchase healthcare across state lines and avoid portions of ObamaCare’s onerous mandates and failing healthcare markets. The President has...

read more

A Victory Over the Abortion-Pill HHS Mandate

By Geoffrey Surtees1507322999866

Today, the Trump Administration took definitive action in defense of religious liberty. The Departments of Health of Human Services (HHS), Labor, and the Treasury issued “ interim final rules ” that, if finalized, will reverse the unconstitutional and illegal HHS Mandate created by the Obama...

read more