The American Center for Law and Justice (ACLJ) has filed an amicus brief in a suit brought by 16 states and two individual plaintiffs challenging the constitutionality of ObamaCare’s individual mandate. As you probably remember, the individual mandate required millions of Americans to buy and indefinitely maintain health insurance or face annual penalties.
The ACLJ was involved in several challenges to the individual mandate after ObamaCare was initially enacted, either representing parties or filing amicus briefs. We filed a critical amicus brief with the Supreme Court of the United States on behalf of 119 Members of Congress in 2012, and the Court agreed with us that the Commerce Clause of the Constitution did not authorize Congress to compel Americans to buy health insurance they did not want. But, according to the Court, the individual mandate could be upheld as a constitutional exercise of Congress’s power to tax because the law imposed a tax penalty on people who did not purchase health insurance. The Court’s decision to label the penalty a tax was surprising for many legal reasons, but also because Congress repeatedly assured Americans that ObamaCare would result in no new taxes.
Fast forward to 2017. Congress passed the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act which, among many other things, eliminated the penalty for not purchasing health insurance. In 2019, Americans no longer had to pay any tax for not complying with the individual mandate. That was good news for those who had previously chosen to pay the penalty rather than buy expensive insurance they didn’t need. But now the only reason that the individual mandate was constitutional was gone. It remained as a bare command to buy insurance, and Congress does not have the power to issue such a bare command.
So sixteen states and two individual citizens sued in federal court asking that the individual mandate be held unconstitutional. The district court agreed with the plaintiffs and the case is now pending before the Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit. Our brief argues:
All three features that supported the [Supreme] Court’s “saving construction” of the individual mandate as a tax are now effectively nonexistent. This year, Americans were no longer required to make the shared responsibility payment with their income tax returns and were therefore not responsible for calculating their payment in accordance with such “familiar factors as taxable income, number of dependents, and joint filing status.” Because no payments have been made, no revenue will be generated. . . . And because the mandatory requirement no longer triggers a tax payment generating revenue for the government, the individual mandate is unmoored from any of Congress’s enumerated powers.
Without a constitutional power to lean on, ObamaCare’s individual mandate, the linchpin of the law, must fall.
The court will hear oral argument in early July.
As we battle in court to defeat unconstitutional, pro-abortion ObamaCare, we urgently need your support. Have your gift DOUBLED today. Have your gift doubled through our Matching Challenge.
Today, the U.S. Supreme Court has vindicated the foundational freedom of our country and the Constitution: the right of religious liberty. In a 7-2 decision , and after nearly a decade of litigation through all levels of the federal judiciary, the U.S. Supreme Court today— once and for all —upheld...
Last week, the American Center for Law and Justice (ACLJ) filed an amicus brief with the Supreme Court of the United States, urging the Court to affirm a Fifth Circuit decision holding the individual mandate unconstitutional. As you probably remember, the individual mandate required millions of...
Today, the ACLJ filed an amicus brief with the United States Supreme Court in support of the Little Sisters of the Poor and the Trump Administration and their efforts to defend religious employers that object to the abortion-pill mandate. The brief was submitted on behalf of over 463,000 ACLJ...
This could finally be the death knell for ObamaCare. The Supreme Court just agreed to hear a THIRD major challenge to ObamaCare, aka the Affordable Care Act, after a group of conservative-led states argued that the law is now, at least in part, unconstitutional. As reported by Fox News : The U.S.