Arson, Violence, and Riots in Response to Excessive Use of Force by the Police is Not the Answer | American Center for Law and Justice
  Search  |  Login  |  Register

ACLJ Profile Completion

Verified

Arson, Violence, and Riots is Not the Answer

By Harry G. Hutchison1591056213320

It is beyond dispute that an injustice was committed by Officer Derek Chauvin when he placed his knee on the neck of Mr. George Floyd, an unarmed man for 8-9 minutes, after he was handcuffed and lying face down on the ground. It is not surprising that Officer Chauvin and one of the other officers implicated in this incident have both been involved in controversial use-of-force incidents previously. Officer Chauvin has now been justifiably charged with third-degree murder and manslaughter for his misconduct leading to the death of Mr. Floyd.

The national and local response to such police misconduct has led to widespread protests, which represent what former President Obama notes is a genuine and legitimate frustration over a decades-long failure to reform police practices.

Nonetheless it is painfully obvious for everyone to see that legitimate protests have in many cases been overwhelmed by the resort to arson, violence, and chaos, activities that put innocent lives, including the lives of our most vulnerable and poorest citizens, at  risk. Anyone who has experienced the widespread and rampant devastation including the destruction of once thriving black middle-class areas that accompanied the Detroit Riots, as I have, should note that unabated violence, arson, and mayhem in response to legitimate grievances only serves the self-interests of politicians rather than the folks on the ground in such neighborhoods. Here are the facts that accord with my experience:

The 1967 Detroit Riots were among the most violent and destructive riots in U.S. history. By the time the bloodshed, burning and looting ended after five days, 43 people were dead, 342 injured, nearly 1,400 buildings had been burned and some 7,000 National Guard and U.S. Army troops had been called into service . . . . In February, 1968, seven months after the Detroit Riots had ended, the commission released its 426-page report.

The Kerner Commission identified more than 150 riots or major disorders between 1965 and 1968. In 1967 alone, 83 people were killed and 1,800 were injured—the majority of them African Americans—and property valued at more than $100 million was damaged, looted or destroyed.

Riots mean that nearby grocery stores and drug stores which provide essential goods and services to the poor disappear. Riots and mayhem signify that African American businesses as well as businesses owned by others disappear in a whiff of smoke. Finally, it means that middle-class residents flee obliterated areas causing such secondary effects as the further devastation of already disadvantaged school districts. So, President Obama was right to decline to excuse violence, or rationalize the participation it, as he argued that if we want our criminal justice system, and American society at large, to operate on a higher ethical code, then we have to model that code ourselves.

While it is obvious that an injustice was committed by Officer Chauvin and while there is evidence that bias afflicts many police departments in the United States, even if there is little evidence of bias regarding police-involved shootings, nonetheless the path to chaos and disorder which produces a disproportionately adverse effect on the most disadvantaged among us is paved by “good intentions.” These “good intentions” are dubiously offered by progressive politicians who refuse to face the facts. This failure to face the facts can be seen in Minneapolis Mayor Jacob Frey’s willingness to order Third Precinct police officers to stand down in the face of violent protests.  After the Mayor pleaded for calm, the rioters swiftly answered his plea by burning the station down as violence spread and devastated the neighborhood while he issued vain platitudes signifying a sound and fury that mean nothing.

Protests in a free society governed by the Constitution are legitimate; but arson, violence, and rioting leads to disorder that hurts vulnerable individuals first and most deeply. Law enforcement is a vital response to any riotous uprising, and the failure to enforce the laws without apology fuels more violence. Liberal mayors and governors, who have governed Blue State cities for more than five decades and who routinely claim to be deeply concerned for the most vulnerable among us, must understand that laws do not enforce themselves and progressives dogmas and passivity conveying the impressions that laws will not be enforced in the face of flagrant harm to cities and neighborhoods is simply a provocation for misconduct. Such provocations will be answered as they provide an excuse for anarchists including Antifa to burn and loot and therefore impose harm on often largely- minority and largely-at-risk populations.

It is time for the American people, irrespective of political affiliation or racial identity to demand that our politicians grow a backbone and flee from the demons of passivity and spinelessness and courageously enforce the rule of law or, alternatively, get out of the way so that intrepid Americans with gumption can reclaim order and avoid the path of chaos that is richly littered with the history of fecklessness by elected officials from New York to Memphis and from Minneapolis to Los Angeles.

All citizens, whether African American, White, Asian, whether rich or poor, whether Democrat or Republican deserve no less than the rule of law. Chaos is not the answer.

Latest in
Public Policy

JSL – 4.8 Million Jobs Added and Special Guest Sean Hannity

By Logan Sekulow1593725449146

The U.S. economy added 4.8 million jobs. On today’s very special Jay Sekulow Live and The Logan Sekulow ReProgram , we discussed the fact that the latest jobs report shows that the economy has added 4.8 million jobs. We also were joined by special guests, Sean Hannity, country superstar John Rich,

read more

Radio Recap – BREAKING: NYC Defunds Police by $1 Billion

By Jordan Sekulow1593645148717

Welcome back to Fear City as the NYPD has one billion dollars cut from its budget. On today’s Jay Sekulow Live , we discussed the defunding of the New York City Police Department, as New York City just slashed one billion dollars from the NYPD’s budget. You’ve got homicide on the rise . You’ve got...

read more

JSL – Remaking the Judiciary: Senate Confirms 200th Trump Appointee

By Jordan Sekulow1593211600892

The U.S. Senate and President Trump are remaking the judiciary. On today’s Jay Sekulow Live , we discussed the fact that the U.S. Senate has confirmed the two hundredth federal judge nominated by President Trump. Nearly a third of the federal appeals court judges in the United States have been...

read more

JUSTICE DENIED: Senate Dems Poised to Block Police Reform

By Jordan Sekulow1592947473822

JUSTICE DENIED. Senate Democrats are poised to block the police reform bill . On today’s Jay Sekulow Live , we discussed the fact that the Senate Democrat leadership seems poised to block Senator Tim Scott’s police reform bill. They appear to be playing politics instead of advocating for real...

read more