Earlier this year, the Trump Administration dealt a painful blow to Planned Parenthood and other abortion businesses through a new rule blocking millions from abortion providers.
Now is the first deadline for the abortion industry to prove it’s complying.
The ACLJ has been involved in this fight to block taxpayer funds under Title X from going to the abortion industry for decades. We submitted official public comments in support of the rule. We also asked ACLJ members to take action and submit their own comments, and you responded in droves. ACLJ members submitted over 13,000 individual comments and accounted for 10% of all comments received by HHS. That’s incredible. Together, we took action, and our combined voices were too strong to ignore.
Also with your support, we filed amicus briefs in District Courts in Oregon and California, as well as at the 9th Circuit Court of Appeals (in both the Oregon and California cases) supporting this rule.
Last month we told you how, despite Planned Parenthood and pro-abortion states’ legal actions to block it, the new Department of Health and Human Services' (HHS) rule blocking millions of tax dollars under Title X from abortion providers was going into effect immediately.
HHS has announced the first date for Planned Parenthood and other Title X recipients to provide “assurance” of compliance is Monday, August 19th.
Because this is a major blow to abortion businesses like Planned Parenthood who have enjoyed using tax dollars through Title X to fund their abortion empire, HHS allowed an appropriate timeline for organizations to make necessary operational changes and prove they are making significant steps toward complying and no longer utilizing Title X monies in a way that subsidizes their abortion business. HHS has set forth a timeline for compliance and reporting requirements to maintain – or lose – eligibility for Title X funds:
In the past, the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Office of Population Affairs (OPA), has exercised enforcement discretion in appropriate circumstances and taken into consideration the time needed for policies to be amended or updated and approved by boards, and for training of personnel in its 4,000 sites on such new or revised policies.
OPA is committed to work with grantees to assist them in coming into compliance with the requirements of the Final Rule.
Given the current circumstances surrounding the implementation of the Final Rule, OPA does not intend to bring enforcement actions against Title X recipients that are making, and continue to make, good faith efforts to comply with the Final Rule. To show good faith efforts to comply with the Title X Final Rule, OPA expects the following from grantees:
- Assurance and Action Plan Documenting Steps to Come Into Compliance – Due by August 19, 2019
- Statement and Supporting Evidence with Compliance Requirements – Due by September 18, 2019
- Statement and Supporting Evidence for Physical Separation between Title X Services and Abortion Services – Due by March 4, 2020.
Even though HHS is giving Title X recipients nearly 8 months to become fully compliant with these new Title X rules, Planned Parenthood has already announced that it will forgo all $60 million dollars in taxpayer funding it normally gets from Title X.
This is a huge victory for life and ensures that Title X funding will no longer be used to subsidize the abortion industry and will go entirely to those entities that only provide comprehensive family planning services.
The Title X family planning program is a federal grant program dedicated to providing low-income families and individuals with family planning and preventive health services.
Grants under Section 1001 assist in the establishment and operation of voluntary family planning projects which provide a broad range of acceptable and effective family planning methods and related preventive health services that include natural family planning methods, infertility services, and services for adolescents; highly effective contraceptive methods; breast and cervical cancer screening and prevention services that correspond with nationally recognized standards of care; STD and HIV prevention education, counseling, testing, and referral; adolescent abstinence counseling; and other preventive health services. The broad range of services does not include abortion as a method of family planning.
And as the express language of Title X provides:
None of the funds appropriated under this title shall be used in programs where abortion is a method of family planning.
The new HHS rules simply implement Title X in the way that Congress originally intended. Yet, despite abortion being clearly prohibited, previous administrations did not implement Title X as Congress intended; and as a result, Planned Parenthood has gotten its hands on roughly $60 million dollars of Title X funding each year. In fact, Planned Parenthood has accounted for as much as 41% of the services funded by Title X.
Planned Parenthood joined forces with more than 20 states’ attorneys general, suing to stop the new rule. But in a victory for life, the 9th Circuit Court of Appeals rejected their request to impose an emergency stay, after it also temporarily blocked injunctions ordered by lower courts in California, Oregon, and Washington – agreeing with arguments we made in our amicus briefs.
Planned Parenthood called the Ninth Circuit’s rulings “devastating.”
That’s the goal. We cannot stand by and let our tax dollars be taken from us only to be handed over to Planned Parenthood so it can kill hundreds of thousands of innocent unborn babies every year.
This is a monumental victory for life and ACLJ members were instrumental in achieving it. This is proof we are winning our battle against taxpayer funded abortion. Every tax dollar we can take away from Planned Parenthood is a step closer to saving a defenseless life.
This win is only the tip of the iceberg. Planned Parenthood receives over $500,000,000 dollars of your tax money every year, even while reporting record profits.
We have much more work to do if we’re going to take down this abortion giant. The ACLJ is dedicated to eliminating taxpayer-supported abortion-on-demand, defending the rights of pro-life professionals and counselors, and fighting for the lives of precious unborn babies.
UPDATE 08.19.19: On Friday, Aug. 16th, the 9th Circuit Court of Appeals denied Planned Parenthood’s request for a full en banc panel (the full 29-seat 9th Circuit) reconsideration of the Title X cases.
The 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals rejected a request from more than 20 states, Planned Parenthood and the American Medical Association to suspend the rules while their case against them is litigated, according to The Associated Press.
A three-judge panel and an 11-judge panel had already decided that the rules could go into effect while the administration appeals district court rulings against them. Oral arguments will be held next month.
As stated in the 9th Circuit opinion:
The full court has been advised of the motions for full court en banc reconsideration and no judge has requested a vote on whether to rehear the matter as a full en banc court. Fed. R. App. P. 35. The motions for full court en banc reconsideration are DENIED.
Now the 11-judge en banc panel will hear the case on its merits in late September. But this move is a resounding victory for life, allowing the HHS rules to remain in effect and requiring abortion providers to begin providing assurances of compliance or lose funding.
We’re taking on the abortion industry at the Supreme Court and fighting to defund Planned Parenthood. Your gift - of any size - will be DOUBLED to save lives. Have your gift doubled through our Matching Challenge.
There has not been a case that is as on track to reverse Roe v. Wade quite like this one. Dobbs v. Jackson Women’s Health Organization came after a challenge against the Mississippi law that banned abortion after 15 weeks. The State of Mississippi asked the Supreme Court to overturn Roe v. Wade and...
The American Center for Law and Justice (ACLJ) just filed an amicus brief in Zimmerman v. City Austin , urging the Texas Supreme Court to hear a case involving the use of taxpayer money to support abortion related services. Texas is at the forefront of the effort to defund Planned Parenthood. In...
Mississippi’s Attorney General Lynn Fitch has just filed a brief asking the Supreme Court to overturn Roe v. Wade and allow for individual states to determine the options for life and abortion. The case, Dobbs v. Jackson Women’s Health Organization , is related to a Mississippi law that was enacted...
Since 1976 federal law has used the Hyde Amendment to protect U.S. taxpayers from directly funding abortions. This law has held up throughout multiple court cases and Administrations. Now, the Hyde Amendment is in jeopardy of being repealed. President Biden and the Left are attempting to eliminate...