Two Briefs Filed in Fight to Expose Illegal Abortion Practices | American Center for Law and Justice
  Search  |  Login  |  Register

ACLJ Profile Completion


Briefs Filed to Expose Illegal Abortions

By ACLJ.org1466102628040

Last summer, the Center for Medical Progress (CMP) began to release a series of videos documenting criminal and other illegal acts of abortion providers, medical researchers, and fetal tissue procurement companies after the group spent a few years compiling an extensive collection of videos and documentation concerning their practices and policies.

Various civil and criminal investigations of the illegal practices exposed by CMP - such as profiting from the sale of fetal organs, manipulating abortion procedures in order to maximize the number of fetal organs that can be harvested, and failing to properly obtain the mother’s consent - are still ongoing. A Congressional Select Investigative Panel continues to review the numerous ways in which federal abortion and fetal tissue donation laws are being broken.

The abortion industry has desperately tried to suppress and delegitimize the work of CMP, including through the use of litigation. We represent former CMP board member Troy Newman – who is also the President of Operation Rescue – in lawsuits filed by the National Abortion Federation (NAF) as well as Planned Parenthood Federation of America (PPFA) and numerous Planned Parenthood affiliates, and we recently filed briefs in both cases.

In the NAF case, the trial court issued a preliminary injunction that prevents the defendants from publishing videos or materials relating to NAF conferences, or sharing such information with anyone, including state Attorneys General or local law enforcement officers, while the case moves forward. The defendants have appealed the decision to the U.S. Court of Appeals to the Ninth Circuit, and we recently filed a reply brief (under seal by court order) that emphasizes that government investigators, and the general public, have a compelling interest in being able to review the videos and materials themselves.

In the PPFA case, we recently filed a reply brief supporting our motion to dismiss the lawsuit. Our brief explains that all of the claims – such as wire fraud, racketeering, and breach of contract – are meritless, so the case should be dismissed. A hearing on the motion is set for July 6.

While these cases have continued to remain in the public eye, there is a lot of misinformation still being passed around in an attempt to help the abortion industry save face. The most common myth is that the videos were deceptively edited to falsely make it appear that members of the abortion, medical research, and fetal tissue procurement industries were committing crimes.

CMP released multiple full-length videos – some over two hours in length – that include relevant conversations from start to finish. In light of the fact that virtually no one wants to participate in, let alone hear, a two hour long conversation, CMP also released shorter highlight videos that focused on key parts of the conversations that deal most directly with illegal activities.

Rather than addressing the substance of the evidence of illegal activity, however, CMP opponents have resorted to the mantra that the videos were “deceptively edited” to make it look like criminal activities were occurring. This mantra is false. The short versions of the videos are no different than a news channel showing a couple of the most intriguing clips of a soon to be aired hour-long interview in a 30-second promo.

To illustrate, the second released video entailed a lunch meeting with Dr. Mary Gatter, Medical Director of a California PP affiliate, which included a lot of off-topic conversation as well as extensive haggling over the specific prices she could get for “donating” various fetal organs. Although it is a federal crime to make any profit from the donation of fetal tissue, Gatter never once tied her price negotiations for fetal organs to the cost of transferring them to researchers.

As the meeting was about to conclude, Gatter infamously joked “I want a Lamborghini” – as in, an exotic car costing upwards of $200,000 – cementing the undeniable fact that, in her mind, she had just closed a lucrative business deal that would net her countless thousands of dollars in pure profit. As we have explained to the Ninth Circuit, there is voluminous evidence of other criminal acts that CMP is currently prevented from discussing, or sharing with law enforcement officials, due to the NAF injunction.

CMP critics also seek to draw attention away from the substance of the evidence of criminal acts occurring within the abortion and fetal tissue research industries by seeking to discredit CMP’s investigative tactics. A bogus criminal charge against CMP investigator David Daleiden was recently thrown out, which is not surprising since CMP complied with all federal, state, and local laws throughout its investigation.

Critiques of CMP’s investigative tactics are meritless because CMP’s work follows in the footsteps of a rich tradition of undercover journalism that seeks to bring important matters of public interest to light that would otherwise remain hidden.

Over a century ago, Upton Sinclair’s novel “The Jungle” was based on appalling things that he saw while working incognito in the meatpacking industry, and numerous journalists have since employed similar tactics – now with the aid of recording devices – to expose illegal, unethical, or unsafe practices concerning everything from animal abuse to shady business practices to online child predators.

There’s an old saying that it “all depends on whose ox is being gored,” meaning that one’s position tends to change when self-interest is at stake. For the most outspoken abortion advocates who support investigative journalism in many other instances – and also support the publication of videos surreptitiously taken inside of pro-life crisis pregnancy centers by pro-abortion groups in an attempt to discredit them – few oxen are as sacred as abortion. In any event, no amount of myths about CMP’s work can change the fact that attempting to get top dollar for the sale of the body parts of babies, as if they were no different than used car parts, is an unspeakably heinous criminal act that should be prosecuted to the fullest extent of the law.

We will continue to vigorously defend our client and the public’s compelling interest in having full access to the important work of CMP as the NAF and PPFA cases move forward.

Stop Harvesting Aborted Babies’ Organs

Pro Life  Signatures


Receive the latest news, updates, and contribution opportunities from ACLJ.

Make this a monthly Tax-Deductible gift.

We're aggressively battling in Congress and in federal court to defeat the abortion industry. Your gift - of any size - will be DOUBLED to save lives. Have your gift doubled through our Matching Challenge.

Email Address is required.
First Name is required.
Last Name is required.
Credit Card Number is required.
Verification Code is required.
Expiration Month is required.
Expiration Year is required.
Receive the latest news, updates, and contribution opportunities from the ACLJ.
Encourage your friends to sign and donate by sharing this petition.
Latest in
Pro Life

Victory for Life: Full Sixth Circuit Upholds Ohio Law Restricting Abortions of Children With Down Syndrome

By Geoffrey Surtees1618513200000

In a 9-7 vote, the entire Sixth Circuit Court of Appeals just upheld an Ohio law that protects unborn children from being aborted when the doctor is aware that the child is being terminated because he or she has Down syndrome. It’s undoubtedly one of the most significant pro-life victories in...

read more

Planned Parenthood Expands Its Diabolical Grip During Pandemic

By Matthew Clark1618340400000

Despite the COVID-19 pandemic, Planned Parenthood recorded its highest number of abortions and largest amount of taxpayer funding to date in 2020. Planned Parenthood continues to record an alarming increase in abortions and U.S. tax dollars year after year. 2020 was no different, setting new record...

read more

Biden’s Title X Rule Change To Fund Planned Parenthood Is a Disgrace

By Mike Pompeo, Senior Counsel for Global Affairs1617973200000

It should come as no surprise that the Biden Administration is reversing the Trump Administration’s Title X policies. Our actions ensured that no American taxpayer dollars were put toward the practice of abortion. None. Not ever. This is but one of the many steps the Biden Administration has taken...

read more

ACLJ Appeals Jury Verdict That Awarded Planned Parenthood Millions

By Erik Zimmerman1617890340000

Several years ago, undercover journalists from the Center for Medical Progress (CMP) released a series of videos that documented criminal and unethical activities related to the sale of the organs and tissue of aborted babies. For example, an abortionist infamously joked, “ I want a Lamborghini , ”

read more