HHS to California: Targeting Pro-Life Pregnancy Centers Violates Federal Law | American Center for Law and Justice
  Search  |  Login  |  Register

ACLJ Profile Completion

Verified

HHS: Targeting Pro-Life Centers Violates Federal Law

By Francis J. Manion1548169200000

Recently, we told you about our important victory in a First Amendment lawsuit we filed against the State of California’s misguided attempt to force pro-life pregnancy care centers to act as referral agencies for the abortion industry. That case went all the way to the U.S. Supreme Court which ruled last June that California’s FACT Act – a measure co-sponsored by then California Attorney General, now Senator and Presidential hopeful, Kamala Harris – violated the free speech rights of our clients. After remand from the Supreme Court, the State agreed to the entry of a permanent injunction against enforcement of the law.

But the case we pursued in the courts was just one prong of our multi-pronged strategy against the FACT Act. While we were litigating the issue under the First Amendment, at the same time we filed Complaints with U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Office of Civil Rights. That agency is charged with enforcing a number of laws passed by Congress over the years aimed at protecting the conscience rights of individuals and entities whose religious beliefs and ethical principles prevent them from advocating for or participating in abortion. Two such laws – the Weldon Amendment and the Coates-Snowe Amendment – prohibit state and local governments from discriminating against individuals or health care entities because they do not provide, pay for, or refer for abortions. Sadly, these laws have mostly remained dormant since their enactment, little used during both Republican and Democratic administrations.

But no longer. Under the leadership of longtime conscience rights advocate, Roger Severino, HHS’s Office of Civil Rights has finally begun to take these conscience-protecting laws seriously. And so, just days ago we received notification from HHS that it has completed its investigation of our Complaints against California’s FACT Act and “determined that California violated the Weldon Amendment and the Coates-Snowe Amendment.”

Additionally, OCR’s Director Severino, in a 12-page “Notice of Violation” letter, informs the State:

California subjected pro-life pregnancy resource centers . . . to an untenable choice that violates the Weldon and/or Coates-Snowe Amendments: violate the FACT Act and face financial penalties, lawsuits, attorney fees, costs, and, fines, or violate their protected right to be free from discrimination on the basis that they will not refer for or make arrangements for abortions.

And while HHS’s action does not impose any penalty in addition to the Permanent Injunction already entered into as a result of our lawsuit, the agency does put the State on notice that, were California to violate the terms of that injunction, it would face the wrath of not only the federal judiciary, but the Executive branch as well in the form of separate enforcement action by the Office of Civil Rights.

This is an important victory for conscience, not only in the specific cases of our three California clients, but perhaps even more important, in what it says about the willingness of the federal Executive Branch to take seriously its distinctive role in protecting pro-life conscience rights. With the legislatures and executives of many states firmly in the hands of Big Abortion, we are sure to see other efforts to squelch the pro-life message at the state level. With this action by HHS, however, we have an important additional tool in our arsenal.

Stop the Shutdown of Pro-Life Centers

Pro Life  Signatures

LOGIN

Receive the latest news, updates, and contribution opportunities from ACLJ.

$20
$40
$60
$120
$240
Make this a monthly tax-deductible gift.

We’re engaged in a comprehensive legal strategy to defend pro-life pregnancy centers. Stand with us. Have your gift doubled today.

Email Address is required.
First Name is required.
Last Name is required.
Credit Card Number is required.
Verification Code is required.
Expiration Month is required.
Expiration Year is required.
Receive the latest news, updates, and contribution opportunities from ACLJ.
Encourage your friends to sign and donate by sharing this petition.
Latest in
Pro Life

NY Abortion Law Forces Dropped Charge in Brutal Murder

By Jordan Sekulow1550262108389

We told you that New York’s barbaric abortion law would have real life (and death) consequences. Unfortunately, we’re already seeing the first evidence of that. An unspeakably savage crime that’s hard to even comprehend, let alone describe, will now go unpunished. A man attacked his pregnant...

read more

The Left’s Troubled Past of Abortion and Eugenics

By Jordan Sekulow1549638243642

The stunning developments of recent days out of Virginia with an extremist abortion-through-birth bill, the governor promoting infanticide, and a total collapse of the top three pro-abortion elected officials, remind us of the Left’s troubled past. First, I detailed exactly what happened in...

read more

Exposing the Abortion Industry’s Control Over New York Law

By Benjamin P. Sisney1549638000000

You’ve read about the shocking legislation abortion advocates passed in New York: the Reproductive Health Act (RHA), that removed New York’s restrictions on abortion and would allow abortion up to the moment of birth. You’ve also heard about how Virginia’s Governor and legislators – bought and paid...

read more

ACLJ Submits Testimony Opposing Barbaric Vermont Bill

By CeCe Heil1549554680278

Today, we submitted our written testimony regarding “Vermont’s Public Hearing on (H.57), An act relating to preserving the right to abortion.” Following the lead of New York, Vermont is considering its own legislation expanding abortion rights. This comes as no surprise as NARAL Pro-Choice America...

read more