In the latest chapter of a seemingly never ending battle over the words “under God” in the Pledge of Allegiance, the Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court unanimously rejected a challenge to the daily voluntary recitation of the Pledge in Massachusetts schools. The ACLJ filed an amicus brief supporting the school district in the case, Doe v. Acton-Boxborough Regional School District.
As is the case in many states, Massachusetts schools begin each day with a voluntary recitation of the Pledge of Allegiance. Consistent with United States Supreme Court cases concerning the freedom of speech, no teacher or student is required to participate or punished for failing to participate.
Atheist and Humanist parents and students, proceeding anonymously, brought suit claiming that this practice violated their right to equal protection under the Massachusetts Constitution. The suit claimed that the practice “marginalizes” Atheists and Humanists as “second-class citizens” who are “unpatriotic” and requested an order preventing the continued recitation of the Pledge so long as it includes “under God.” There was no evidence that the students had ever been punished, bullied, criticized, or otherwise mistreated for declining to recite the Pledge.
The ACLJ filed an amicus brief arguing that the phrase “under God” in the Pledge reflects the historical fact that the United States was founded upon a belief in God, and a belief that our inalienable rights come from God, not the government. The brief also noted that the United States Supreme Court and various other federal and state courts had recognized that patriotic exercises with religious references, such as reciting the Pledge, are constitutionally sound. Additionally, the brief explained that this lawsuit was simply a repackaged version of previous lawsuits challenging the Pledge that were rejected.
The court unanimously rejected the plaintiffs’ claims, noting that the voluntary recitation of the Pledge “is intended to instill values of patriotism and good citizenship.” The court held that there was no discrimination against Atheist and Humanist students because all students were free to decline to recite all or part of the Pledge. The students’ alleged feeling of being stigmatized and excluded due to their non-participation was not evidence of discrimination.
This decision is another win for common sense and another loss for those who would like to strip any and every remnant of religion from the public arena.
In the Declaration of Independence , after affirming the principle of equality based on the “Laws of Nature and Nature’s God,” the document continues, “We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights,
As Memorial Day weekend approaches, America is hopeful to return to complete normalcy. It is time for America to reopen and for people to get back out in the world. We have seen how important your local and state government can be during this past year. This just proves elections have consequences.
When I arrived at West Point, I was issued three items, among others, vital to serving my country: a uniform, a rifle, and a copy of The Federalist Papers. This collection of essays, written by some of the greatest minds among our Founders – Alexander Hamilton, James Madison, and John Jay – remains...
President Trump has left office. Joe Biden is now President of the United States. Today on Sekulow , we said thank you to President Donald J. Trump. The 45th President of United States secured many victories during his term, such as furthering the cause of defending the unborn and standing up for...