One of Justice Scalia’s most memorable moments came in a compelling dissent to one of the recent ObamaCare cases. He cut through the majority opinion’s ambiguous, contorted, and complex legal justification for upholding the “SCOTUScare” exchanges in just two words: “Pure applesauce.”
Pondering the brilliance of his wit and rhetoric (that even his staunchest critics on the Court acknowledge) got me thinking about the inexorable absurdity that is ObamaCare.
While exceeding the brilliant brevity of 2 words, consider this analogy.
What if instead of the societal ill of people lacking medical care, ObamaCare were to instead tackle the problem of hunger. Here’s how it would work.
It would force people who are too poor to buy good food (but not poor enough to get food stamps), under threat of tax penalties (which they also couldn’t afford), to purchase gift cards to grocery stores. Not food, gift cards.
It would require you to purchase these gift cards monthly, at least 9 months a year, or face tax fines and penalties. You would not however be forced to use these gift cards nor would it matter if you needed them, but any unused gift cards would be completely valueless the next year.
Recognizing that this would cause financial strain on those who were already financially strapped, it would mandate that states establish their own grocery stores, or in the alternative, the federal government would set one up. Does this drive down the price of food? No, but that’s irrelevant. However, the government would give you a $5 coupon toward the purchase of a gift card to any of these grocery stores.
A paternalistic government forcing a mandate they can’t afford on the American people, and it still doesn’t fix the real problem.
And there you have the stupidity of ObamaCare.
This article is crossposted at RedState.com.
Take action with the ACLJ at the Supreme Court to defeat ObamaCare and have your tax-deductible gift doubled today. Have your gift doubled through our Matching Challenge.
Your data is secure. Learn More »
On President Trump’s first day in office, the ACLJ has already achieved a significant victory as the President adopts a key ACLJ recommendation aimed at bringing down pro-abortion ObamaCare. As one of his first acts, President Trump issued an Executive order directing the Secretary of Health and...
The Affordable Care Act (ObamaCare) was enacted with great fanfare and unrivaled deception in 2010 as part of a duplicitous plan to destroy America’s private health care system as we know it. The Speaker of the House at the time, Nancy Pelosi, infamously said in March 2010 that, “we have to pass...
Promising to bring costs down and increase access on the one hand, and enacted with enormous fanfare and unequaled deception on the other, the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act (also known as Obamacare) became law in 2010. This law was perhaps the most ambitious social legislation in...
Thanks to two decisions of a federal court of appeals handed down today ( here and here ), it is now almost certain that the U.S. Supreme Court will decide next term whether the Obama administration can force religious entities, institutions, and groups -- under pain of severe financial penalties...