ACLJ Presents Oral Argument in Korte HHS Mandate Appeal | American Center for Law and Justice
  Search  |  Login  |  Register

ACLJ Profile Completion

Verified

Oral Argument in Korte HHS Mandate Appeal

By Edward White1369336575000

Yesterday, May 22nd, I had the privilege to present oral argument before the United States Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit, based in Chicago, on behalf of our clients in Korte v. U.S. Department of Health & Human Services.

Korte is one of the seven lawsuits the American Center for Law & Justice (“ACLJ”) has filed challenging the HHS Mandate.

The Mandate requires many employers to arrange and pay for employee health insurance that covers contraceptives, abortion-inducing drugs, sterilization, and related education and counseling.

If an employer refuses to comply with the Mandate, the employer faces significant fines and penalties. Many employers are exempted for various reasons, but there is no exemption for businesses that are operated by individuals with religious objections to arranging and paying for the required coverage.

Here, we represent Cyril and Jane Korte, a husband and wife, and their family-owned construction company, Korte & Luitjohan Contractors, Inc. The Kortes seek to manage and operate their Illinois company pursuant to their Catholic faith.

Their Catholic faith prevents them from arranging for, paying for, providing, and otherwise supporting employee health insurance coverage that provides the products and services required by the Mandate, except in limited circumstances.

If they follow their faith and do not provide such coverage, the federal government will impose annual fines of approximately $730,000.

This past October, we filed a motion asking the federal trial court to enter a preliminary injunction to prevent enforcement of the Mandate, which would have applied to the Kortes and their company on January 1, 2013, when their employee health plan had to be renewed.

The trial court denied our motion in December, and we immediately appealed that decision to the Seventh Circuit Court of Appeals. We also filed an emergency motion for injunctive relief to stop application of the Mandate before January 1st.

In late December, the Seventh Circuit granted the emergency motion, which permitted the Kortes to comply with their faith while the Seventh Circuit considers our appeal of the trial court’s denial of the preliminary injunction motion. In that regard, we filed our opening brief on appeal this past January and our reply brief in March.

The oral argument before the Seventh Circuit, the audio of which you can listen to here, was an additional opportunity for us to present our case to the appellate court and, in particular, to answer any questions of the three judges who will be deciding the case.

We now await the Seventh Circuit’s written decision, which we anticipate will be issued in the coming months.

We will continue to keep you informed about this and the other important cases in which we are involved against the HHS Mandate.

Latest in
ObamaCare

Ending the ObamaCare Individual Mandate

By Harry G. Hutchison1510850681175

Last year shortly after the election, the ACLJ issued its Agenda for the Future . We urged the incoming administration to immediately repeal and replace ObamaCare with a focus on the advancement of a patient-centered, consumer-driven program that emphasizes choice and competition . Today, we renew...

read more

The President’s Executive Order on Healthcare

By ACLJ.org1507904666276

President Trump just signed an Executive Order “to Promote Healthcare Choice and Competition.” This Executive Order allows small businesses to unite to purchase healthcare across state lines and avoid portions of ObamaCare’s onerous mandates and failing healthcare markets. The President has...

read more

A Victory Over the Abortion-Pill HHS Mandate

By Geoffrey Surtees1507322999866

Today, the Trump Administration took definitive action in defense of religious liberty. The Departments of Health of Human Services (HHS), Labor, and the Treasury issued “ interim final rules ” that, if finalized, will reverse the unconstitutional and illegal HHS Mandate created by the Obama...

read more

6 Keys to Repealing ObamaCare

By ACLJ.org1506028658479

The GOP has put forward their final attempt to repeal ObamaCare this year: The Graham-Cassidy-Heller-Johnson bill, also known as Graham-Cassidy . Vice President Mike Pence has aptly described this as “ our last best chance to stop and turn [ObamaCare] around .” Time is of the essence because the...

read more