Iran: How to Fix a Bad Deal | American Center for Law and Justice
  Search  |  Login  |  Register

ACLJ Profile Completion


Iran: How to Fix a Bad Deal

By Wesley Smith1524855600000

In the first official State Visit of the Trump Administration, French President Emanuel Macron came to Washington for three days.  It was a visit marked by much ceremony as we celebrate our historic relationship with America’s oldest ally.  France has been a friend to the people of the United States since the days preceding the American Revolution.  Part of Macron’s mission was to convince President Trump to keep the U.S. in the Joint Comprehensive Plan of Action (JCPOA), or Iran Nuclear Deal.

Macron, in an effort to negotiate with Trump, suggested that rather than withdraw from the JCPOA, the agreement must comprehensively address concerns over Iran’s future ability to obtain nuclear weapons and concerns over increased Iranian military action in the Middle East.  In other words, rather than withdraw from the deal, the JCPOA should be adjusted and expanded to allay the concerns of the United States.

Macron’s plan has four pillars:

  1. Severely curb Iran’s Uranium Enrichment Program until 2025.

    Questions:  What happens after 2025, which is less than seven years away?  And, as importantly, exactly how will the West curb that program?  As the plan stands now, there are no spot inspections of Iran’s nuclear sites allowed except by Iranian inspectors and outside inspectors must give Iran advanced notice before showing up. The JCPOA is ripe for abuse and secret research and development by Iran on nuclear technology.

  2. Ensure longer-term curbs on Iran’s nuclear program beyond 2025.

    If one believes Iran’s rhetoric, there will be no “tweaking” of the Iran Nuclear Deal.  Iran’s Foreign Minister wrote on Twitter that his nation’s compliance with the present agreement is “either all or nothing.”  So, again, the larger question is “How, exactly, will the nations who signed the JCPOA (the Five Permanent Members of the UN Security Council, plus Germany and Iran) get the Iranians to expand the present agreement in order to curb their nuclear program beyond 2025?”

  3. Restrict Iran’s ballistic missile program.

    This idea would be laughable if it were not so serious.  Despite UN restrictions on Iran’s ballistic missile program, it continues to defy those restrictions even now, with impunity!  As recently as April 18th, on Army Day, Iran paraded a new missile that is its most advanced medium-range ballistic missile to date, one capable of striking Israel or any other nation in the region.  It is suspected that Iran is already cooperating with its ally North Korea on advanced missile technology.  We know for certain that North Korean scientists are stationed in Iran, and vice versa.

  4. Contain Iran’s activities in the Middle East, particularly in Yemen, Syria, Iraq and Lebanon.

    Again, the question is “How?” 

    Today Iran supports and supplies the Houthi Rebels in Yemen, rebels who regularly fire Iranian missiles into the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia.  Iran continues to station its militias in Iraq and is attempting to interfere with upcoming Iraqi elections.  In Lebanon, Iran’s proxy, Hezbollah, has one of the largest non-state militaries in the world.  Hezbollah has hundreds of rockets and missiles, including new ones with a more sophisticated guidance system supplied by Iran, in Lebanon and these weapons have one target:  Israel.  In Syria, Iran has stationed its ground and air forces in Syria and plans to keep them there.  Under the so-called “De-confliction Agreement” with the U.S., Turkey and Russia, Iran now has troops stationed along the border with Israel. Iran’s intent is to have a permanent military presence in Syria and prop up the brutal regime of Assad.

Finally, in his speech before a Joint Session of the United States Congress, Macron stated: “Iran shall not possess any nuclear weapons.  Not now, not in five years, not in ten years, never!”  His statement is reminiscent of similar statements made by the United States and its allies about North Korea.  North Korea now has nuclear weapons and the world is trying to figure out what to do about it.

On Tuesday, Iranian President Hassan Rouhani warned of “severe consequences” for the U.S. should it withdraw from the Iran nuclear deal.  Iran’s Foreign Minister Zarif stated that if the U.S. withdraws from the deal, Iran would restart its nuclear weapons program, even if the other nations of the JCPOA stay in the agreement.  More than likely, as North Korea has done before them, Iran is already secretly continuing its research and development of nuclear weapons.  We cannot know for sure, as the inspection program of the JCPOA is so convoluted and weak that it is virtually impossible to know with certainty where Iran is in its quest for nuclear weapons.  Once they have these weapons, the game changes and the options of what to do decrease markedly.

As with many complex geo-political problems, the devil is in the details.  President Macron gave a good speech, full of hope and promise.  The four pillars he presented sound good.  But problems remain because there is no realistic way to achieve these lofty goals short of cancelling the JCPOA, reenacting the strong sanctions against Iran, and returning to the policies that were in place until President Obama committed the U.S. to an agreement that is weak, ill-advised, and unenforceable.

President Trump has an important decision to make by May 12. He must decide whether or not Iran is living up to its commitments in the JCPOA.  If not, the question then becomes, what do we do about it?  Benjamin Netanyahu, who knows that Israel has more to lose in this proposition than anyone else correctly explains our dilemma: “The  deal  has to be either fully fixed or fully nixed.”

Expose and End Obama’s Iran Deal

Middle East  Signatures


Receive the latest news, updates, and contribution opportunities from ACLJ.

Make this a monthly tax-deductible gift.

As we battle the U.N.’s anti-Israel taxpayer-funded lawfare slush fund at the ICC, we need YOU. Have your gift DOUBLED today to defend Israel.‬ Have your gift doubled through our Matching Challenge.

Email Address is required.
First Name is required.
Last Name is required.
Credit Card Number is required.
Verification Code is required.
Expiration Month is required.
Expiration Year is required.
Receive the latest news, updates, and contribution opportunities from ACLJ.
Encourage your friends to sign and donate by sharing this petition.
Latest in
Middle East

JSL - President Trump: ISIS Leader Died Like a Dog

By Jordan Sekulow1572295435533

Yesterday, President Trump announced that the leader of ISIS, Abu Bakr al-Baghdadi, died during a U.S. Special Forces raid over the weekend. Last night was a great night for the United States and for the world. A brutal killer, one who has caused so much hardship and death, has violently been...

read more

Radio Recap: Understanding the Conflict in Turkey

By Jay Sekulow1570654077324

There’s been a lot in the news over the last few days regarding the situation with Turkey, Syria, and the Kurds. On today’s Jay Sekulow Live , we took our time to discuss the very interesting convergence of activity in Turkey. You have Turkey looking to take on Syria, specifically the Kurds in...

read more

JSL: Iran Attacks Saudi Arabia. U.S. “Locked and Loaded”

By Jordan Sekulow1568663615501

In breaking news, Iran directly attacked Saudi Arabia, and according to President Trump, the U.S. is “locked and loaded.” On today’s Jay Sekulow Live , we discussed an attack Saturday on a Saudi oil facility, drastically affecting oil output. It was initially believed to be a drone attack by the...

read more

Taliban Peace Deal was Not A Deal

By Wesley Smith1568152594036

President Trump decided over the weekend to cancel secret, direct talks with leaders of the Taliban, after yet another suicide bombing that killed another U.S. soldier. While the talks, scheduled for Camp David, were a secret—the efforts for a “peace deal” with the Taliban has been very public and...

read more