Federal Court to IRS: Produce Documents Within 30 Days | American Center for Law and Justice
  Search  |  Login  |  Register

ACLJ Profile Completion

Verified

Federal Court to IRS: Produce Docs

By Carly F. Gammill1434138659251

A federal district court in New Hampshire issued an order earlier this week giving the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) 30 days to produce, for the court's review, a set of documents it has refused to produce in response to a FOIA request issued last June by the nonprofit Citizens for a Strong New Hampshire. This order is a direct response granting a portion of the relief the ACLJ has requested on behalf of Citizens for a Strong New Hampshire.

Last summer, Citizens for a Strong New Hampshire requested from the IRS, pursuant to the federal Freedom of Information Act (FOIA), communications between two New Hampshire Members of Congress (Jeanne Shaheen and Carol Shea-Porter) and specified IRS officials, including Douglas Shulman, Steven Miller, and Lois Lerner. After Citizens for a Strong New Hampshire waited over four months for a response, we filed a federal lawsuit on behalf of the organization based on the IRS's improper withholding of documents in violation of FOIA.

In filings with the court, the IRS described the search it performed to locate responsive documents and attempted to explain the basis for withholding 51 documents in their entirety. Based on the IRS's filings, however, it was clear to us that the agency failed to meet its burden to demonstrate that it performed an adequate search or that the 51 documents were properly withheld pursuant to a FOIA exemption.

In simple terms, information that is exempt need not be disclosed to a FOIA requester. The agency bears the burden of clearly demonstrating that documents withheld are in fact exempt. The IRS's filings, however, stated only that the documents withheld contained or consisted of exempt information, raising concerns that some of the documents should be disclosed subject only to redaction of any exempt information they might contain. In a subsequent filing the IRS attempted to backpedal, asserting that the withheld documents consisted entirely of exempt information, but this contention is clearly at odds with the agency's prior equivocal statement.

After we pointed out to the court the glaring inconsistencies in the IRS's statements (statements made under oath to a federal court), and asked that the IRS be required to produce the withheld documents for the court's inspection, the court issued an order on Monday giving the IRS 30 days to do just that.

This order demonstrates the IRS's utter failure to persuade not only us at the ACLJ but a federal judge herself of the veracity of its testimony. The unfortunate reality is that we have reached the point where the American people can have no confidence in one of our executive governmental agencies absent direct oversight by the federal judiciary. It is inexcusable that this day has arrived, but we are hopeful that the intervention of the court here will provide the assurances necessary to ensure that the rights and interests of our client are adequately protected and that any public information improperly withheld by the IRS will be brought to light.

At the same time, the ACLJ continues to challenge the IRS in a separate matter – our ongoing federal lawsuit against the IRS for unlawfully targeting dozens of Tea Party and conservative groups because of their political beliefs.

We intend to hold the IRS accountable - for its failure to be transparent in communications with members of Congress and for its unlawful actions in an unconstitutional targeting scheme.

Petition to End IRS Abuse

Free Speech  Signatures

LOGIN

Receive the latest news, updates, and contribution opportunities from ACLJ.

$20
$40
$60
$120
$240
Make this a monthly tax-deductible gift.

We're taking on the unlimited resources of the Obama Admin. in federal court to hold the abusive IRS accountable. Have your gift doubled. Have your gift doubled through our Matching Challenge.

Email Address is required.
First Name is required.
Last Name is required.
Credit Card Number is required.
Verification Code is required.
Expiration Month is required.
Expiration Year is required.
Receive the latest news, updates, and contribution opportunities from ACLJ.
Encourage your friends to sign and donate by sharing this petition.
Latest in
Free Speech

BREAKING: Senate Judiciary to Subpoena Twitter CEO Over Censorship

By Jordan Sekulow1602798084449

The Senate Judiciary Committee is going to subpoena Twitter CEO Jack Dorsey over censorship. On today’s Jay Sekulow Live , we discussed the Senate Judiciary Committee announcing its intentions to subpoena the Twitter CEO over censorship of conservatives and even the press and to hold a hearing next...

read more

The Johnson Amendment’s Continued Impediment to the Church

By Mark Goldfeder1600960199483

The Johnson Amendment is the controversial provision in the U.S. tax code that prohibits all 501(c)(3) non-profit organizations from participating or intervening in “any political campaign on behalf of (or in opposition to) any candidate for public office.” As it relates to churches and other...

read more

Big Tech Censorship and Bias – What Do We Do About It?

By Craig Parshall1591794000000

On May 28th, 2020 President Donald Trump released his Executive Order (“EO”) titled, “Preventing Online Censorship.” In releasing the full text of the EO, mainstream media outlets like NBC news were quick to criticize the Presidential order, characterizing it as just a “response to Twitter,” which...

read more

Leftist Doxing of Conservatives and the First Amendment

By Laura Hernandez1570115343105

Last week, the American Center for Law and Justice (ACLJ) filed an amicus brief in two related cases, Americans for Prosperity Foundation (AFP) v. Becerra and Thomas More Law Center (TMLC) v. Becerra. Both cases began in California when the Attorney General required all charities to submit lists of...

read more