Victory: Federal Court Rejects Establishment Clause Challenge | American Center for Law and Justice
  Search  |  Login  |  Register

ACLJ Profile Completion


Victory: Establishment Clause Rejected

By Laura Hernandez1434052717801

Today, the Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit unanimously held that a Tennessee Public School District did not violate the Establishment Clause of the First Amendment when it contracted with a Christian school for its "alternative school."  Faced with a severe budgetary shortfall, the Jefferson County School Board was forced to close its alternative school, a program mandated under Tennessee law for all 7th through twelfth graders with learning or other disabilities.  In an effort to preserve alternative school educational services, however, the school district signed a contract with the Kingswood School, a nonprofit Christian entity, licensed by the Tennessee Department of Mental Health and Developmental Disabilities. The agreement with Kingswood saved the school district $170,000 a year, and provided educational services that would otherwise have been unavailable to the school district's students.

Kingswood employed state-licensed teachers for the alternative school and excluded all religious instruction from the curriculum and from free counseling services provided to the students. Nevertheless, religious images in the school's chapel (where no school assemblies were ever held) and scripture verses on some Kingswood documents provoked two disgruntled teachers to sue the school district. The teachers claimed that the school district's agreement with the Kingswood school violated the Establishment Clause.

The ACLJ filed an amicus brief arguing that the teachers' claims were meritless because the Supreme Court of the United States has held in several cases that providing government  funded educational services on religious school premises does not violate the Establishment Clause.  Our brief also pointed out that a decision for the teachers would require attributing the private speech of Kingswood to the School Board, and would ignore the overriding fact that the School Board had contracted with Kingswood solely for economic reasons.

The Sixth Circuit agreed, ruling that 

it is clear that the taxpayers, School Board, parents, and students all benefited from the relationship between the Board and Kingswood. While this benefit was being conferred, parents and children received only slight exposure to religious content. The exposure they did receive stemmed from Kingswood’s pre-existing status as an unapologetically Christian institution. The mere status of Kingswood as a religious organization does not itself give rise to endorsement. The First Amendment does not demand a wall of separation between church and state.

The court gets it exactly right.  This is a tremendous victory.  We will continue fighting to ensure that the Constitution is not misconstrued and that religious liberty is protected.

Tennessee Reviews Its Curriculum

By ACLJ.org1462899847838

Islamic indoctrination of children in public schools is a concern for parents across the country. As we previously reported , educators have been presenting fundamental Islamic beliefs as facts to students. Across the nation, students have been forced to recite the Five Pillars of Islam, make...

read more

True or False?

By Carly F. Gammill1450370357057

Whatever happened to the days of “reading, writing, and ‘rithmetic”? The days when students and parents could expect that educators would teach the preparatory skills necessary for college and life as a productive citizen without feeling the need to inject their own agendas into the instruction?

read more

Indoctrination in Our Public Schools?

By Jay Sekulow1442240764028

What if your child or grandchild’s public school forced them to write out the Shahada – the Islamic conversion creed – while ” having skipped Christianity ”? What if your child’s study guide had a section called “Origins of Islam” that included statements such as, “Around the age of 40, the angel...

read more

No Islamic Indoctrination in School

By Carly F. Gammill1429625977564

“Pretend you are a Muslim.” This was the instruction given in a class assignment at Union Grove High School in Union Grove, Wisconsin, requiring students to take on the persona of a Muslim in order to write a “point of view” essay in which they discussed their daily Islamic religious practices and...

read more