ACLJ: Supreme Court Must End Special Privileges for Church-State Separationist Taxpayer Plaintiffs | American Center for Law and Justice
  Search  |  Login  |  Register

ACLJ Profile Completion


Supreme Court hears case about President's faith-based initiatives

February 28, 2007

(Washington, DC) The American Center for Law and Justice (ACLJ), which focuses on constitutional law, said today the Supreme Court has an important opportunity to put an end to federal taxpayer lawsuits by church-state separationists.  The Supreme Court today heard oral arguments in the case of Hein v. Freedom From Religion Foundation (U.S. No. 06-157) a case that also focuses on a challenge of using taxpayer dollars to fund a program of President Bushs faith-based initiative.  The ACLJ filed an amicus brief with the high court in support of the federal governments position.

There is no constitutional conflict in using tax dollars to fund faith-based initiatives, said Jay Sekulow, Chief Counsel of the ACLJ who attended todays oral arguments.  The Supreme Court should leave the faith-based initiative alone and focus on removing the special privileges afforded to atheists and others who are antagonistic to religion.  The church/state separationists have been given a free pass in federal court to bring Establishment Clause lawsuits. They have not had to show that a law or government activity actually injured them in any way before they could challenge it in federal court. All they had to do was show that they were taxpayers. That is not only unfair, but wrong.  Were hopeful the Supreme Court will put an end to the special treatment given to these plaintiffs.

In the Hein case, separationist taxpayers challenged a federal faith-based initiatives program. The federal district court in Wisconsin dismissed the case, ruling that taxpayers had no standing capacity to sue because there was no federal grant at issue. But a federal appeals court reinstated the suit ruling that the separationists had standing to challenge the use of federal funds to run the challenged program. The federal government appealed to the Supreme Court.

In its friend-of-the-court brief in support of the federal government, the ACLJ points out that no federal taxpayer suits are allowed in any other context aside from Establishment Clause suits challenging federal spending. That exception, the ACLJ brief notes, rests on the 1968 decision of Flast v. Cohen. Subsequent to Flast, however, the Supreme Court has refused to expand Flast and has rejected each and every argument the Court made in support of the Flast decision.

The ACLJ brief is posted here.

Sekulow added:  This case should not be used as a test case on how taxpayer funds are spent.  Instead, the high court needs to bring an end to the special treatment given to atheists and other separationists. The Flast precedent has created an uneven playing field because it empowered every disgruntled atheist to make a federal case out of any hint of religion in a government action.

Led by Chief Counsel Jay Sekulow, the American Center for Law and Justice specializes in constitutional law and focuses on religious liberty litigation.  The ACLJ is based in Washington, D.C.

Latest in

ACLJ Roundup: Border, Bible, and Business

By Jordan Sekulow1622756748187

There is a lot going on right now, and our ACLJ team is breaking it down. President Biden has officially terminated former President Trump’s “Remain in Mexico” program amidst the record high surge at our border. The “Remain in Mexico” program allowed tens of thousands of migrants to remain in...

read more

ACLJ, Members of Congress File in Court On Biden’s Tax Cut Ban (Recap)

By Jordan Sekulow1618002113455

We just took major action in court to fight back against President Biden and the radical Left’s unconstitutional overreach. Today on Sekulow , we discussed the breaking announcement that the ACLJ is filing a critical amicus brief in court to challenge President Biden’s power grab to control state...

read more

This Easter, Do Not Be Afraid, But Remember Our Christian Brothers and Sisters Around the World Facing Violence and Persecution

By Jay Sekulow1617357660000

“Do not be afraid.” Those were the words of the angel who appeared to Mary Magdalene and Mary, the mother of Jesus, according to Matthew 28 : The angel said to the women, “Do not be afraid, for I know that you are looking for Jesus, who was crucified. He is not here; he has risen, just as he said.

read more

ACLJ Presses State Dept. on John Kerry’s Secret Meetings (Recap)

By Jordan Sekulow1616619728081

The ACLJ has filed a FOIA request with the U.S. State Department regarding John Kerry’s secret meetings with Iran. Today on Sekulow , we discussed John Kerry’s clandestine meetings with Iran and how the ACLJ is pressing the State Department to find out what they know about these meetings. You may...

read more