The Welfare State’s War on Religious Liberty | American Center for Law and Justice
  Search  |  Login  |  Register

ACLJ Profile Completion


By David French1325201666000

The case for limited government is becoming increasingly inseparable from the case for religious liberty. Yesterday, the New York Times published a lengthy article on the battle between the Catholic Church and various arms of the leviathan welfare state. The church is battling Obama administration requirements that Catholic schools and hospitals cover contraceptives in their health plans, battling Obama administration decisions to freeze Catholics out of contracts to aid sex-trafficking victims, and battling the state of Illinois over state requirements that Catholic charities place kids with same-sex couples. These fights come after the Catholic church famously shut down its adoption services in Massachusetts rather than bow to state demands that it place children in same-sex households. The Times sets ups the battle for religious liberty as a matter of right of access to government contracts:

Critics of the church argue that no group has a constitutional right to a government contract, especially if it refuses to provide required services.

But Anthony R. Picarello Jr., general counsel and associate general secretary of the United States Conference of Catholic Bishops, disagreed. “It’s true that the church doesn’t have a First Amendment right to have a government contract,” he said, “but it does have a First Amendment right not to be excluded from a contract based on its religious beliefs.”

While I agree completely with Anthony Picarello’s comment, we shouldn’t lose sight of a larger truth: Because of the massive expansion of government, religious organizations are often unable to even conduct their traditional charitable functions without heavy state regulation. In other words, the “government contracts” or “government benefits” at issue are a required component of the charitable work. Don’t believe me? Try running a foster-care program independently. Try offering a health-insurance plan for your employees without dealing with a maze of federal regulations. So this is not a simple matter of a private organization trying to feed from the federal trough but instead of a religious organization trying to carry out a mission that predates the very formation of our nation and being barred from doing so because the state has decided it knows best.

This represents a fundamental change in our social contract and one that — for all the yammerings of the “strict separation” crowd — actually results in the government leaping straight into the most sacred choices of our religious institutions. The Catholic Church is entirely correct to stand against Illinois and the Obama administration and defend its 2,000-year-old mission and purpose.

This article is crossposted at National Review Online.

Latest in

We Must Not Follow in the Footsteps...

By Nicole Smith1457734516425

The craze a presidential election cycle creates often makes it difficult to keep sight of what our Founding Fathers intended for us as citizens of this United States of America. When the political-rapidness begins to sweep over me – before it fully envelopes my whole being - I try to take a step...

read more

Election: Don't Overlook the Bureaucracy

By Jay Sekulow1454452784878

With the political season in high gear, it is clear Americans are concerned about the top issues like terrorism and the economy. And with the focus now squarely on the presidential race, it’s important to remember there’s another issue that demands the attention of all Americans – a burgeoning...

read more

Bureaucratic Corruption: IRS Illegally...

By Jay Sekulow1454089126060

The Obama Administration’s IRS continues to become an ever-more-tangled web of bureaucratic blunders and corruption. The investigative report from The Daily Caller is worth reading in full. It’s mind-boggling how the revolving door of corruption and ineptitude combines to create an IRS absolutely...

read more

How the Government is Stealing Your...

By ACLJ.org1453822711046

Your rights are being violated and your freedom is under attack. The Obama Administration’s out-of-control bureaucracy continues to discriminate against conservatives and Christians, passes job-killing regulations that hurt our economy, and seethes with corruption that results in adoptive parents...

read more