Lawfare Update: Can Israel Defend Its Borders? | American Center for Law and Justice
  Search  |  Login  |  Register

By David French1310072630000

In a previous post, I defined lawfare as a form of asymmetric warfare that abuses domestic and international legal norms to accomplish tactical and strategic goals that can’t be won on the battlefield. Today brings news of the latest example, a U.N. report accusing Israel of violating U.N. resolutions when it responded with deadly force when demonstrators attempted to breach its border fence in May.

This critique rests on an utterly novel reinterpretation of international law. To recap, Israel remains in the midst of a multi-decade face-off against states (and terrorist entities) that refuse to recognize its borders and indeed its very right to exist. Despite decades of military conflict and multiple shooting wars, Israel has not been dislodged, and there is zero indication that Syria, Lebanon, Hezbollah, or any organized entity in the Middle East possesses the raw military power to move Israel from its current borders. Further, under international law, a sovereign nation has the ability to use armed force to defend its borders against incursions from belligerent states and belligerent entities.

On May 15, 2011, thousands of protesters — acting with the consent and cooperation of forces hostile to Israel — stormed Israel’s border fence. A large number of those protesters engaged in violent acts, including throwing stones, “petrol bombs,” and attempting to physically tear down the fence itself. Israel issued verbal warnings, fired warning shots, and then — finally — used deadly force. Could Israel have accomplished the same goals with different tactics (such as tear gas or other riot control mechanisms)? Perhaps. Was Israel required to use such tactics to defend its border? Absolutely not.

Indeed, international mandates requiring the use of nonlethal force do nothing more than encourage further incursions and diminish Israel’s ability to defend its borders. But that of course is the core goal of lawfare — to win for Hezbollah a victory in New York that it could never win in Israel.

Latest in

Pray for the Peace of Jerusalem

By Marshall Goldman1446234633162

King David admonished us to pray for the peace of Jerusalem. Perhaps we should not just pray for Jerusalem, but for the entire state of Israel. The current geopolitical climate within and surrounding Israel illustrates why prayers and aggressive advocacy are needed. Israel faces immense threats not...

read more

Violence and Terrorism Against Israel

By Shaheryar Gill1445443091280

Israel, our strongest ally in the Middle East, is facing yet another episode of jihadist violence and terrorism against its innocent citizens. Since October 1, 2015, Palestinian terrorists have carried out more than two dozen gun and knife attacks, killing at least ten Israelis and wounding several...

read more

Wailing Wall an Islamic Holy Site?

By Matthew Clark1445374240296

In news so bizarre it could only be yet another chapter in the world’s anti-Semitic hate for Israel, a U.N. agency is poised to designate the Jewish “Wailing Wall” as an Islamic holy site. Yes, you read that right. The U.N. Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization (UNESCO) is reported...

read more

Palestinian Terror Intensifies

By Jay Sekulow1444171281435

In the wake of Palestinian Authority (PA) President Mahmoud Abbas’ United Nations address in which he announced Palestine’s repudiation of the Oslo Accords , violence has broken out in the West Bank and Jerusalem. With Palestine’s abandonment of the Oslo Accords, the set of agreements between...

read more